Showing posts with label rhetoric. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rhetoric. Show all posts

Sunday, November 8, 2026

A Thought On the 2026 Midterm Elections

 


I am not going to obsess over the details. There are plenty polls, pundits, and demographics out there for anyone interested. The election was clearly a mandate against an authoritarian Trump style government. I know the Vice President has come out and said it was due to the war against Iran (is it a war now?) – but it is far deeper than that. It is also far deeper than politics as usual.

The wake-up call for all Americans is that we do not have a perfect democracy.  Historians are all well aware of that and know that what happened in 1776 is not the way the current government should be run because it ignores what happened in 1863.  The so-called Founding Fathers had documents that outlined a rough sketch of the Republic in theory but it took another 100-200 years to approach the theory that “all men are created equal.”  Like most people my age – I lived through overt racism even in areas where there were only white people.

Apart from the appeal to history, the other requirements are that everyone involved stay law abiding and cooperative, and live in the real world.  The first two years of the Trump government saw unprecedented levels of corruption in the form of quid pro quo pardons of convicted financial criminals, mass pardons of insurrectionists including those involved in injuring police officers, self-enrichment of the President and his family in situations where they were supposed to be representing the interests of the American people, and failure to investigate or prosecute masked federal agents who shot and killed two Minnesotans.  These incidents just scratch the surface.  At the same time, the complete report by Special Prosecutor Jack Smith and most of the files related to the Epstein scandal were suppressed.  

To a psychiatrist all of this can be regarded as sociopathic behavior.  By that I mean, any person or group who has the ability to take what they want from you or force you what to do what they want in spite of your preferences.  That can range from somebody pointing a gun at you in an alley to take your money to someone getting access to your bank accounts on the Internet without your knowledge.  The power exerted over you can be overt or covert, but the common factor is the person exercising that power is not bothered by what they are doing.  When asked about it they may suggest their victim was “just in the wrong place”, “should have known better” or they did something to “deserve it.”  There is no conscience, moral code, or accountability.

In modern society, there is nuance in the form of conflict of interest.  Conflict of interest laws and policies were developed to prevent the silent exploitation made possible by elected and public positions.  These polices exist and are codified in the federal government.  We have just seen an administration that chose to completely ignore them as well as the Emoluments Clause in the Constitution. It can be argued that this was facilitated by a pro-Trump Supreme Court.  The message to Congress is that the law in this area needs to be tightened up.  The Republic can no longer depend that an elected President will avoid what are potential massive conflicts of interest and the associated compromises.  Although historical precedent worked until Trump, there can be no doubt that the President is focused on the interests of the Republic.  There is already a move to apply a no stock trading rule to Congress and the same considerations apply there. 

The level of corruption was a top issue for voters in this election after it was apparently ignored for the first two years of the Trump presidency. There was a long list of issues ignored where Trump supporters apparently gave him and his version of the Republican party a complete pass.  To name a few others – incompetent cabinet choices, a complete lack of decorum when it came to Presidential behavior, alienating most of our allies and trading partners, destroying American competitiveness by shutting down scientific research and turning space research over to private industry, killing, detaining, and deporting US citizens without an investigation, turning public health over to a health and wellness influencer with no expertise in public health, withholding funds from American universities based on political biases, attempting to interfere with state midterm elections at least 30 times, defunding the largest insurer of maternal, substance use, and mental health treatment in the US; defaming top America scientists and other distinguished members of the civil service, firing 10-12% of the civilian civil service without cause; weakening the US military by arbitrarily removing staff at the highest levels of command for political reasons and then proceeding to demonstrate that the US could not win a war against Iran or keep the Strait of Hormuz open.   That is just a partial list of what comes to my mind as I type the essay.  When it comes to specifics – the list gets much longer.    

In the post-election spectacle so far, I have seen the following themes: What does it mean for the Democrats?  What does it mean for the Republicans?  What does it mean for the Supreme Court?  What does it mean for the stock market?  The Vice President is blaming the loss on the War in Iran, etc.

None of the analyses looks at the real problem and that is - American voters.  The voters typically get a pass by just saying: “It is a free country and I get to vote for whoever I want.”  That is true – but why would you not want to avoid the misery and national embarrassment of the last 2 years?  How can Americans be so blind that they elected a President like Trump in the first place?  That is the only critical question that needs to be asked and here is why.  We cannot afford to be fooled twice.  In fact, we are not out of the woods yet – we might not even be able to be fooled once.  Trump is still President for 2 more years and if the dynamics are still in place that elected him – the Republic is not out of danger. 

The first crucial observation is that many people are not able to see reality as it exists.  Based on facts alone, Trump was the worst possible candidate for the Republican party. His only positive resume point was his reality TV show, apart from that he had multiple real-life business failures, a history of not treating contractors and employees poorly, criminal convictions, civil lawsuits, charges of racism and misogyny, and charges of sexual abuse.  He made public statements that would have immediately disqualified any other candidate.  For many entry level jobs, he would not have passed the background check.  Despite all of these factors, tens of millions voted for him on the premise that he was going to “drain the swamp (of corruption)”, restore jobs that were being lost to modernization, lower taxes, and avoid wars.  That disconnect should have been the first clue.

Even though Trump brags about his ostentatious lifestyle and seeks to names buildings and institutions that he encounters after himself - working class voters suddenly believed he was going to help them.  Why would anyone believe him as opposed to anyone else with that background?     

Much has been made of Trump’s charisma. The type of charisma he has is often overlooked.   Real charisma is affiliative and pro-social.  It is optimistic, hopeful, and genuinely interested in inclusion and one’s fellow man.  Empathy is present and used to support the emotional states and well being of others.  Any displays of anger are directed at tasks and unfairness.  People like to be around charismatic people.

Dark charisma is pseudo affiliative with rapid shifts to non-affiliative distancing if there is disagreement or criticism.  Positive emotions are largely performative. Any observation of a Trump rally shows him pandering to and entertaining his audiences who seem to regard him as a benign and somewhat humorous older relative. There is the predictable progression to name-calling and personal attacks on individuals, discussion of non-existent conspiracies (Deep State, election fraud), false promises and more general prevarication.  The crowd keeps chuckling no matter how dark he gets. 

Papers have been written about this dark personality style and the elements (psychopathy, Machiavellianism, narcissism, etc) – but like the application of all psychiatric concepts to Trump it is not necessary.  A psychiatric diagnosis or formulation is not necessary to notice the disconnect of a constellation of behaviors from reality or their historical precedents. 

The second clue or disconnect is how much of what he says is factually incorrect or plainly rhetorical. The rhetorical statements often violate social norms.  The third clue is how much is just self-aggrandizement like unsubstantiated claims that everything he does is “the best” and that he is generally superior in every way.  Expect no apologies or acknowledgements that mistakes were ever made.  He has to come across as the strong man no matter what has happened. If he feels slighted in any way – he is on the attack with lawsuits, investigations, law enforcement, and the military.

For observers who do not identify with the behaviors – these rallies are bizarre – like newsreels from the 1940s.  They appear to be from another era.  People have not seen Presidents act like this at any point in their memory.  Since Trump never talks about policy or a clear vision for where the country is headed and what the hope is for the future - watching him perform is profoundly alienating.  How can this guy really be President of the United States?  What does it say about this country?

Historical comparisons were just beginning at the time of this post. There are the comparisons to Nixon and the Watergate scandal.  That resulted in the same mandate for Democrats after Nixon resigned in 1974.  Of course, that was at a time when Gerald Ford was blamed for pardoning Nixon.  In the current era, Trump pardoned all of the January 6 insurrectionists including those accused of violent crimes along with 70 financial criminals while excusing their restitution payments of $1.5B.  Many of those pardons appear to be in exchange for significant payments or donations.  As the linked article points out – Trump has made corruption the rule rather than the exception. At the same time Trump made Minnesota a target of fraud allegations while ignoring the fact that the state has some of the lowest fraud statistics in the country.  

There is a more accurate historical precedent for the Trump strategies that reaches back to the 1950s.  The table that follows provides a direct comparison of tactics used by Trump to those used by Senator Joseph McCarthy.  The conventional wisdom of McCarthyism today is influenced primarily by Hollywood portrayals of the effect on the entertainment industry.   McCarthyism is synonymous with unsubstantiated claims and attacks on people for alleged communist activity by using a number of political, social, and legal tactics. McCarthy was a US Senator from Wisconsin from 1947 to 1957 but in 1950 he gave a speech saying the US State Department had been infiltrated by communists.  The Army McCarthy hearings in 1954 resulted in discrediting both McCarthy and his attorney Roy Cohn, effectively ending the attacks and investigations.  Roy Cohn is a direct line to Donald Trump who taught him these techniques when he was his attorney.     


Tactic / Dimension Joseph McCarthy And The Second Red Scare (1940s–1950s) Donald Trump And Administration Tactics
1. Unsubstantiated And Sweeping Accusations
  • Claimed to hold lists of "known Communists" within the U.S. State Department with constantly shifting numbers.
  • Relied on dramatic press conferences right before print deadlines to make unverified charges of subversion and treason.
  • Regularly alleges broad, unevidenced conspiracies (e.g., claiming the "Deep State," "weaponized DOJ," or "rigged" systems actively target him and his allies).
  • Employs high-profile social media statements and rally speeches to make sweeping allegations of treason or corruption against critics before formal evidence or investigation.
2. Presumption of Guilt And Erosion of Due Process
  • Applied "guilt by association"—labeling individuals subversives simply for attending progressive events or reading certain literature.
  • Framed invoking the 5th Amendment as an implicit admission of treason ("Fifth Amendment Communists").
  • Frequently pressures law enforcement and investigative bodies to open probes into political opponents regardless of formal evidence.
  • Asserts that federal investigations targeting his actions or inner circle are inherently corrupt "witch hunts" while demanding immediate legal action against political rivals.
3. Blacklisting and Institutional Ruin
  • Stripped security clearances and enforced job terminations across government, academia, and entertainment (the Hollywood Blacklist).
  • Required compulsory loyalty oaths for teachers, civil servants, and university professors as a condition of employment.
  • Revoked or threatened top-secret security clearances for former intelligence officials, military leaders, and civil servants who criticized White House policy.
  • Weaponized executive orders, tax-exempt status threats, and funding cuts against university administrations, non-profits, media groups, and law firms that permit critical viewpoints or protests.
4. Bureaucratic Investigation and Informing
  • Staged televised Congressional hearings (via HUAC and Senate committees) designed to publicly humiliate, intimidate, and interrogate targets.
  • Coerced individuals into naming friends and colleagues to prove their own political loyalty.
  • Utilizes executive oversight bodies, presidential commissions, and partisan congressional investigations to subpoena, publicly rebuke, and pressure critics.
  • Imposes strict loyalty tests across federal agencies (e.g., Schedule F civil service reclassification) to fire non-partisan bureaucrats and replace them with loyalists.
5. Exploitation of National Fear And Moral Panic
  • Capitalized on Cold War anxieties—such as the Soviet nuclear threat, the Fall of China, and the Korean War—to frame all left-leaning political dissent as an existential threat to the nation.
  • Capitalizes on border security concerns, cultural polarization, and economic fears—framing political opponents, protestors, and mainstream media outlets as "enemies of the people" or threats to national survival.
6. Negative Effects on Science and Public Health
  • Purging Top Scientists: Revoked security clearances and denied passports to world-class scientists (e.g., J. Robert Oppenheimer, Linus Pauling) over political views, delaying critical research like the structure of DNA.
  • Depoliticizing and Halting Health Initiatives: Targeted progressive medical groups (e.g., Association of Internes and Medical Students), effectively crushing early advocacy for universal health coverage and community medicine.
  • Institutional Censorship: Forced researchers and universities to abandon socially oriented public health studies in favor of "safe," non-controversial defense projects to retain federal funding.
  • Institutional Purges & Ideological Oversight: Replaced career agency leadership, installed political appointees over scientific advisory boards (e.g., CDC, FDA), and terminated or reclassified thousands of career scientists.
  • Suppression & Censorship of Public Health Data: Altered or delayed official scientific reports (such as CDC morbidity reports), purged federal health databases, and restricted communications on vaccines, disease modeling, and environmental health.
  • Defunding Targeted Research: Suspended or cancelled federal grants for long-term clinical trials, public health programs, and international scientific collaborations deemed politically objectionable.


One of the more interesting aspects of the above comparison is how McCarthyism was much more far-reaching than the entertainment industry.  Medicine, science, and public health were all affected in service of the false narrative that communists were everywhere.  As a chemistry major – I had no idea that Linus Pauling was refused a passport to the UK by this group because of his pacifist activity during this era.  That resulted in him not having access to high resolution x-ray diffraction photos that led Watson and Crick to determine the double-helical structure of DNA.  At the time Pauling had a competing triple-helix model.  J. Robert Oppenheimer who oversaw the development of the first US nuclear weapons was affected as well as medical research.  The parallels between these political initiatives are more than coincidence. 

The bottom line for me is that we may have avoided an ongoing nightmare.  The assumptions of 10 generations of Americans that we have an inherently stable system of government that has the interests of all of us in mind has been proven wrong by the Trump government. At one time or another we have all seen the paraphrase: “...democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.”  We may have seen a glimmer of that with the judicial branch in holding the line against Trump’s voter interference and malicious and politically motivated prosecutions.  Beyond that there is a good reason why the average American has been anxious over Trump’s attacks on just about everyone including allies while taking a benign approach with dictators and autocrats.     

The Trump supporters don’t get a pass.  I don’t care if they were average voters, members of Congress, or working for right wing media companies.  They were the proximate cause of this near catastrophe.  They have to work a lot harder the next time and as I tried to point out in this post – you don’t have to be a psychiatrist to figure it out.  You don’t have to use psychiatric diagnoses or jargon to figure it out. You just have to look at what does not make sense.  

All of the clues are right out there in the open.  You have to figure out why you are ignoring them.

 

 

George Dawson, MD, DFAPA

 

Supplementary 1:  Single issue voters. Immediately after the election results came in I started to see posts about abortion and how abortion supporters were evil.  I expect there will be similar posts about guns, climate change, and foreign policy.  If you think a national election should be determined by these issues especially the extremist positions – you are just plain wrong.  The MAGA defeat is proof of that.  Clearly, they got all of the anti-abortion, pro-gun, and anti-climate change vote and that was not nearly enough.  I heard several voters interviewed that they did not like how some state anti-abortion laws made them accomplices if they failed to report any abortions, they knew about or assisted women seeking abortions.  Single issue votes will not save the economy, keep us out of unnecessary wars, or improve the security of Americans against cyberattacks from other countries. I would argue that the current administration is clear proof of that.  

Supplementary 2:  Even though I have an interest in rhetoric and have many posts here that seek to simplify it – I avoided it for the most part in this post.  I will add at this point that the three most common rhetorical devices used by this administration are fomenting anger leading to emotional reasoning, misdirection, and false equivalencies.  I can produce many examples of each upon request. You can also see them satirized on the Comedy Channel and that might be easier to digest.  

Supplementary 3:  In the post election analysis, the number of clips I saw with Republicans claiming that communism, socialism, and Sharia law were on the ballot were striking.  Of course none of those statements are remotely true and yet they were some of the most vehement claims. Those claims are right out of the McCarthy-Cohn playbook from the 1950s.  


Graphics Credit:  US Capitol by Martin Falbisoner, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons



Saturday, August 1, 2026

The MAGA GOP Against Anthony Fauci, MD...


 

The Lie

The Facts

Lie 1: "Fauci lied about masks."

The Claim: repeatedly asserts Fauci intentionally lied to the public to manipulate them or that his changing guidance proved he was deceptive.

In March 2020 (the early weeks of the pandemic), public health officials—including Fauci—advised the general public against buying N95 surgical masks to prevent a severe shortage for front-line healthcare workers, given the initial belief that COVID-19 spread primarily through large droplets and surfaces. As airborne transmission and asymptomatic spread became clear in April 2020, guidance shifted to universal cloth mask-wearing. Scientific adaptation to new data was re-framed by critics as a malicious "lie."

Lie 2: "Fauci created/funded COVID-19 in Wuhan."

The Claim:  Repeated claims state that Fauci personally authorized "gain-of-function" research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology that directly created the SARS-CoV-2 virus.

While the National Institutes of Health (NIH) did fund grants to EcoHealth Alliance for bat coronavirus research in China, independent scientific panels, the NIH, and intelligence reviews clarified that the specific bat coronaviruses studied under those sub-grants were genetically distinct from SARS-CoV-2 and could not have evolved into the pandemic virus. The political rhetoric, however, repeats the "Fauci created the virus" line to frame a public servant as a criminal perpetrator.  Some circles suggest there was homicidal intent.

Lie 3: "Fauci personally forced lockdowns and school closures."

The Claim: characterizes lockdowns, school closures, and business restrictions as unilateral mandates handed down personally by "Dictator Fauci."

Under the U.S. federal system, public health mandates (closing schools, restricting indoor dining, stay-at-home orders) were legally enacted by state governors and local public health departments—not federal advisory scientists. Fauci served as an advisor whose task force issued recommendations, but he lacked any statutory executive power to pass laws or order closures. See Supplementary 7 (below).

Lie 4:  "Fauci lied when he said vaccines stop 100% of transmission."

The Claim: Asserts that public health officials promised the original COVID-19 vaccines would permanently block all infection and transmission, calling subsequent variant breakthrough cases "proof of a lie."

Clinical trials in late 2020 measured efficacy against symptomatic disease (which was ~95% for original strains). While early real-world data showed significant reduction in transmission against original variants, the emergence of mutated variants (like Delta and Omicron) eroded protection against infection while maintaining strong protection against severe illness and death. The shift in viral evolution was reframed as a deliberate institutional falsehood.

Lie 5: “Fauci made millions of dollars directly off the COVID-19 pandemic.”

The Claim:  made millions through secret royalty checks paid by pharmaceutical companies for COVID-19 vaccines. The claim frames him not as an independent public health scientist, but as a compromised figure using federal authority to enrich himself and corporate allies.  In this hearing there was a comments that he was “enriching himself through the use of federal employees.”  There has also been a longstanding complaint that Dr. Fauci is the “highest paid federal employee and he makes more than the President.”  That is true but it is full disclosure and according to federal regulations.

-Dr. Fauci holds no patents and receives no royalties related to any COVID-19 vaccines or treatments (including the Pfizer, Moderna, or Johnson & Johnson vaccines).

-FOIA disclosures obtained by watchdog groups showed that the NIH and its scientists received third-party royalties for older, pre-pandemic medical innovations (such as early HIV/AIDS research from decades prior). However, sensationalist headlines falsely claimed that these past, unrelated payments were "COVID-19 vaccine profits."

-Dr. Fauci has repeatedly stated—dating back to interviews with the Associated Press and BMJ in 2004/2005—that he attempted to refuse statutory royalty payments from earlier research (such as an interleukin-2 treatment developed for HIV/AIDS) because he felt it posed a potential conflict of interest.  Because federal law required the agency to issue the funds, Fauci pledged to donate 100% of his royalty payments to charity.

-Federal Salary: As the former Director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) and Chief Medical Advisor, Dr. Fauci was one of the highest-paid federal civil servants, earning a fixed annual government salary (~$480,000 before his retirement in late 2022). This salary was set by federal civil service pay scales, completely independent of vaccine sales or corporate profits.

- Public Filings: Under the Ethics in Government Act, Fauci’s financial disclosures—including his investments, stock holdings, and outside income—are subject to strict federal conflict-of-interest audits and are a matter of public record. His filings show no stock holdings in individual pharmaceutical companies; his personal investments are held in broad mutual funds, municipal bonds, and standard retirement accounts.  His income is subject to strict federal conflict-of-interest audits and is a matter of public record. His filings show no stock holdings in individual pharmaceutical companies; his personal investments are held in broad mutual funds, municipal bonds, and standard retirement accounts.

-In February 2021, Tel Aviv University awarded Dr. Fauci the Dan David Prize for lifetime achievement in public health and his leadership during the HIV/AIDS and COVID-19 crises.  After tax withholdings and administrative fees, the direct deposit received by Fauci totaled $899,960.  The National Institutes of Health (NIH) ethics office has long-standing regulations (5 C.F.R. § 2635.204(g)) that allow federal researchers and doctors to accept bona fide, prestigious awards for scientific achievement from non-profit or educational institutions, provided the award is approved by an agency ethics officer.  Before accepting the Dan David Prize (and other academic honors throughout his 50-year career), Fauci submitted the award for official NIH ethics review, which formally authorized him to accept the cash prize.


I saw the various clips but don’t have to watch the entire debacle.  It was the usual exercise in rhetoric as I watched the US slide farther and farther from reality.  After all this was a debate about the COVID pandemic that officially ran from March 11, 2020 to May 5, 2023.  It has been over for more than 3 years.  The argument can easily be made there are more pressing public health and safety problems at this point ( foodborne illness outbreaks, vaccine preventable disease outbreaks (measles, pertussis), toxicology emergencies (lead poisoning), wildfires, that are direct  products of the policies of this administration and currently endanger thousands of Americans. 

In addition, the elimination of Medicaid and SNAP benefits endanger millions more.  Medicaid is the nation's largest payer of mental health and substance use disorder care, and the primary funding vehicle for addressing Social Determinants of Health (SDOH) (housing, food security, and transportation).  Medicaid is also the single largest payer of maternity care in the US covering 40% of all births. In the midst of those problems the HHS Secretary has decided that he knows something about mental health and has decided he knows more about what medications and treatments people with those disorders need to take.  So why is the pandemic being relitigated while this administration is ironically making American unhealthy again?

The most straightforward answer is because they can.  Trump and his allies have tapped in to strong anti-science, anti-knowledge, and anti-expert biases in the US and used them to their advantage.  They routinely scapegoat and vilify anyone who they consider to be an enemy or outsider and that is a very low bar.  To end up in the enemy camp – all you have to do is disagree with them.  Disagreement is easy when they have produced so many ideological decisions that have no rational basis.  The list of those irrational decisions can fill volumes at this point.  I will focus on the dynamics of the Fauci hearing.   

This hearing was clearly a set up by Paul, and Fauci made that point in his opening statement – specifically that Paul had an unhealthy obsession with him and had threatened to jail him. This is apparently because of Paul’s conspiracy theory that the COVID virus (SARS-CoV-2) was a virus modified in a Chinese lab and accidentally released.  He claims that Fauci knew something about this despite Fauci’s diary entry of 2021 documenting that the latest genetic information made manufacture in a lab an impossibility. The remainder of the hearing was essentially Fauci taking the Fifth Amendment against self-incrimination.  Anyone who knows how the government works would be foolish to start any discussion in such a biased proceeding. That is especially true in the case of Fauci who has a pardon from former President Biden. In this setting it is easy to suggest perjury incidents and file those charges in the absence of any real evidence for the original charge.

At least some of the impetus for these hearings was the personal diary of Dr. Fauci.  Paul apparently was given this access by HHS Secretary Kennedy who discovered it on their servers.  At this point I do not know if it was Dr. Fauci’s naiveté about recording personal notes on a government server or something else.  I do know that it is common sense that diaries are not written for public disclosure.  To publish this as Paul has done shows that it is all part of a general smear campaign and an attempt to suggest that the things nobody says out loud are really “lies”. 

Like almost all of the current governments tactics this all comes down to rhetoric at several levels.  The first is just the usual scapegoating and rage-bating.  Fauci is an intellectual, an elite, etc.  He is not like the rest of us but he likes to tell us all what to do.  This is our chance to rise up and throw him in jail.  Of course, the rage baiting caused more problems than that for Dr. Fauci and his family.  He has been threatened with harm and many of those threats were considered serious.  He had a government security detail from 2022 until it was terminated by Trump on January 24, 2025. It has not prevented further public threats in some cases by public figures who have no idea who Dr. Fauci is or what he has accomplished.  They are generally focused on one of the lies in the above table.

I thought about adding a section here on the academic references to the various rhetorical devices used by autocrats and fascists.  But I will keep it simple.  Trump and his administration use them all to distort reality, provoke anger in his base, and further divide the country.  One of his advisors was very clear about it and called it “flooding the zone.”  There is plenty written about that process in academic references, but you can see how it works in real time just by watching the news every day. Trump promotes the lie that the 2020 election was “stolen” and none of his cabinet nominees will answer that question in Congressional hearings.  Suddenly we have unconstitutional interference with local elections and pending federal legislation that will eliminate tens of thousands of eligible voters.

The pattern is clear.  Initiate a divisive issue, never admit it is false or involves any wrongdoing, and keep repeating it.  Ignore the fallout even if that includes casualties on the streets of Minnesota or in an unnecessary war.  Blame everyone else and never acknowledge mistakes even when they are obvious to everyone else. Academic references about logical fallacies are unnecessary in these scenarios. This is where the lies about Anthony Fauci come from.  When he was coming up with solutions to the horror of the pandemic, Trump and his cohort were suggesting bleach, ivermectin, and hydroxychloroquine – all completely ineffective and in some cases dangerous.  In fact with the “pile on” effect from this hearing one of those cabinet members took to social media to claim he had stockpiles of hydroxychloroquine that would have saved thousands of people.  That is another completely inaccurate claim.     

 In the final analysis. It all comes down to whether or not you are a rational person.  You may feel encapsulated by a Democrat or Republican label.  That clearly does not insulate you from unnecessary wars, the erosion of civil rights, the dismantling of the public health infrastructure, a deteriorating climate and environment, a worsening health care system, diversion of most economic resources to the wealthy, enabling convicted criminals and fraudsters to commit further crimes and trying to reimburse them for jail time, and using government resources to attack innocent American citizens.  It does not insulate you from the fact that we have an administration that has appointed people to serve in the cabinet who have no qualifications.  None of this passes muster as politics as usual much less rational decision-making.

So – be a rational person.  Respond to facts and not rhetoric. Notice when there is an appeal to your emotion rather than your decision-making. Recognize the obvious fallacies when you see them – like the frequent name-calling and witch hunts. 

Get the USA back on track again…

 

George Dawson, MD, DFAPA 

 

 

Supplementary 1:  The American Public Health Association (APHA) has come out on social media in support of Dr. Fauci.  Several medical organizations have done this in the past related to COVID and HIV controversies. It is time that every physician organization does the same thing and does it now.  I have been an elected official in physician organizations and there is always a “big-tent” concern.  In this case that would mean supporting Dr. Fauci would alienate any dues paying Republicans. As I hope to have pointed out in the above post – this is larger than political labels.  In the above table you can choose to be in column 1 or column 2.  Column 2 is the rational choice.  

Supplementary 2:  If you want to see how some of these lies played out in real time - I have a post here that recorded some of what football star Aaron Rodgers  had to say about Dr. Fauci back in 2024.  Mercifully the video has been taken down but the lies and distortions are still all there.  He goes even further suggesting that both the HIV and COVID pandemics were created to respond to only specific drugs and enrich Dr. Fauci and Pharma.  I am not saying that Rodgers is lying but he certainly is repeating them almost exactly as outlined in the above table.  The information to refute his assertions was widely available at the time and in the case of HIV for decades earlier. 

Supplementary 3:  Commentators on this issue always soft pedal any direct confrontation of the lie.  For exam on Lie #2 - Fauci funded the creation of the pathological COVID virus (already walked back by Sen. Paul to GOF and not the pandemic virus) it is common to hear:  "Well I don't agree with that but I do disagree with the way the pandemic was handled."  First off what part do you disagree with?  Fauci's job was keeping up with the research and trying to change guidance on the fly while hospitals were overwhelmed and tens of thousands of people were dying. Anyone in that situation is going to make what they consider to be the most conservative recommendation to save the most people.  Secondly, by making that hedging statement you are endorsing Lie #3.  Fauci did not personally close down anything.  That was all local officials.  

Supplementary 4:  I have a great interest in airborne viruses.  Because of that interest I documented the transition in thinking about COVID transmission from droplet nuclei to airborne on this blog.  The date was April 8, 2020.  This confirms row 1 in the table. 

Supplementary 5:  Highly recommend the nonpartisan Annenberg Foundation's FactCheck.org to fact check anything this party or administration has to say about Dr. Fauci or the COVID pandemic.

Supplementary 6:  Since I posted this around noon on August 1, 2026 I have heard the following in the media:

"Fauci is responsible for 8 or 9 millions deaths."

"Fauci is worse than Joseph Mengele."

And from a national comedian: "Of course Fauci lied about gain of function."

No he did not.  All of these statements confirm what is said in the body of my post and will probably be repeated every day if you are paying attention.  To be a rational person you have to be intentional.  All of these inaccurate statements cannot be brushed off or in the case of comedians - laughed at.  Pick a column and stay there.

8/2/2026:  Day 2 of the Fauci hysteria.  Many people have taken to social media to reinforce the message of the MAGA Republicans today portraying Fauci as a megalomaniac and blaming him for everything from vaccination side effects to their kid having to wear a dirty mask to school for 8 days in a row.  One of the worst examples I have seen was an excerpt posted about a meeting with a CIA official that supposedly informed him of a lab leak and suggesting he covered this up.  It is clear from the diary entry that he considered both the information and informant unreliable and actually suspicious.  This same author likened the situation to finding out Dick Cheney wrote in his diary that he knew there were no weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.  The huge problem with that comparison is not only what was recorded at the time (unreliable source) - but that genetic analysis of the virus showed it was not produced in a lab.  The real comparison here is from law enforcement and that is:  1:  eyewitnesses are unreliable and this informant would not even qualify as an eyewitness.  According to rules of evidence this is hearsay.  2:  In court - hearsay is not evidence, but genetic analysis is.  

And then there was this interview of RFK, Jr by CCN's Dana Bash.  It was full of misinformation including some of the misrepresentations in the table above.  Ashish Jha, MD provides a bit of commentary at the end and has the stunning disclosure that he now believes the pandemic virus was a lab leak.  I have searched everywhere for what he is basing that opinion on and so far have found nothing.  No matter what side of the issue you are on - all of this agitation does absolutely nothing to address either future outbreaks or the outbreaks that are occurring right now.  

 Supplementary 7:  A reminder of what actually happened and what the timeline was (see Lie #3).  States clearly ended emergency declarations before the dates declared by Trump HHS Secretary Azar,  Trump himself, and Biden ending it early.  Dr. Fauci was not in that loop.  Red states did it before Blue states and there was a mortality gap due to COVID with red states having a higher mortality. 

Feature

Federal Emergency Declarations

State Emergency Declarations

Primary Purpose

Funding, regulatory flexibility, and administrative waivers.

Direct police power over public movement, business operations, and health rules.

Scope

Unlocked federal funds (FEMA, CARES Act), allowed FDA Emergency Use Authorizations (EUAs), expanded telehealth, and provided extra Medicaid matching funds.

Enforced stay-at-home orders, indoor mask mandates, business closures/capacity limits, and school rules.

Jurisdiction

Did not have the legal power to issue nationwide lockdowns, close private businesses, or mandate masks for the general public.

Had direct legal authority under state constitutions to issue and enforce mandates.

 

The Two Federal Declarations

The federal government established blanket, nationwide emergency statuses covering all 50 states:

  1. Public Health Emergency (PHE): Declared by HHS Secretary Alex Azar on January 31, 2020 under Section 319 of the Public Health Service Act. It officially ended on May 11, 2023 (6 days after the World Health Organization declared an end to the pandemic on May 5, 2023).
  2. National Emergency: Declared by President Donald Trump on March 13, 2020 (retroactive to March 1) under the National Emergencies Act and Stafford Act. President Biden signed a bipartisan congressional resolution ending it slightly early on April 10, 2023.


State Actions:


Florida:

 April 30, 2020 (Stay-at-Home Order Ends):

DeSantis issued a 30-day "Safer at Home" order on April 1, 2020. He allowed it to expire on April 30, 2020, initiating Phase 1 of state reopening on May 4.

 September 25, 2020 (Lifting Business Limits & Banning Mask Fines):

DeSantis moved Florida directly into Phase 3 reopening. This order:

Removed all state-level capacity limits on restaurants, bars, and businesses.

 Prohibited local municipalities from enforcing mask rules or public health orders with fines or penalties, effectively gutting local mask mandates.

 May 3, 2021 (Invalidating All Local Mandates):

DeSantis signed Senate Bill 2006 and issued an immediate executive order that canceled all remaining emergency orders and mask mandates passed by cities or counties statewide.

 June 26, 2021 (State of Emergency Expires):

DeSantis allowed Florida's official statewide COVID-19 State of Emergency to lapse without renewal.

 July 30, 2021 (School Mask Mandates Prohibited):

As schools prepared to reopen for the fall, DeSantis issued an executive order banning local school boards from requiring students to wear masks.

 States That Ended Emergency Declarations Before Florida

  • Michigan (October 12, 2020):

The Michigan Supreme Court ruled in October 2020 that Governor Gretchen Whitmer lacked the legal authority to maintain executive emergency powers without legislative approval, effectively striking down the state of emergency early.

  • Wisconsin (March 31, 2021):

The Wisconsin Supreme Court struck down Governor Tony Evers’ emergency declaration, ruling he violated state law by repeatedly extending 60-day emergency orders without legislative consent.

  • Alaska (April 30, 2021):

Governor Mike Dunleavy allowed the legislature's extended public health emergency declaration to lapse on April 30, shifting the state into an administrative recovery phase.

  • North Dakota (April 30, 2021):

Governor Doug Burgum officially rescinded North Dakota’s executive order declaring a state of emergency at the end of April.

  • Oklahoma (May 4, 2021):

Governor Kevin Stitt issued an executive order terminating Oklahoma’s state of emergency in early May, citing falling cases and wide vaccine availability.

 

References:

1:  Rasmussen A.  RFK Jr is Asking to Be Proven Wrong Again So Here Are 40 Examples From Just One CNN Interview.  August 4, 2026:  https://rasmussenretorts.substack.com/p/rfk-jr-is-asking-to-be-proven-wrong

If you read one reference this is the one I recommend.  Dr. Rasmussen is a working academic virologist who knows more about these issues than anyone in the Trump administration or their affiliated media networks.  

2:  Gounder C.  Underlying Conditions https://www.celinegounder.com/

Dr. Gounder is an infectious disease specialist and epidemiologist and on this blog she exhaustively looks at the claims being made by politicians and whether or not they are accurate.  That include 3 parts on the Fauci hearing but also RFK's autism claims and the recent problems with food safety.  You should not be too shocked by the results.  

3:  Robertson L.  The Wuhan Lab and the Gain-of-Function Disagreement.   FactCheck.org.  Posted on May 21, 2021 | Updated on July 1, 2021  https://www.factcheck.org/2021/05/the-wuhan-lab-and-the-gain-of-function-disagreement/

4:  Robertson J, MacDonald J.  Fauci and Paul, Round 2.   FactCheck.org Posted on August 11, 2023 | Updated on August 23, 2024  Posted on July 22, 2021 | Updated on August 19, 2021 https://www.factcheck.org/2021/07/scicheck-fauci-and-paul-round-2/

“There’s no evidence that Fauci lied to Congress, as Paul asserted in the July 20 hearing, given that the NIH unequivocally backs up Fauci’s statement that the grant-backed research “was judged by qualified staff up and down the chain as not being gain-of-function.”

In a May 19 statement, NIH Director Dr. Francis S. Collins said that “neither NIH nor NIAID have ever approved any grant that would have supported ‘gain-of-function’ research on coronaviruses that would have increased their transmissibility or lethality for humans.”  “

5:  Jaramillio C, and Yandell K.  RFK Jr.’s COVID-19 Deceptions.  FactCheck.org Posted on August 11, 2023 | Updated on August 23, 2024  https://www.factcheck.org/2023/08/scicheck-rfk-jr-s-covid-19-deceptions/

6:  Kaiser J.  Under fire from Republican senators, Fauci takes the Fifth at COVID-19 hearing.  Science July 29, 2026:  https://www.science.org/content/article/under-fire-republican-senators-fauci-takes-fifth-covid-19-hearing

7:  American Society of Microbiology Letter in Support of Dr. Fauci.  July 28, 2026:  https://asm.org/articles/policy/2026/july/asm-letter-to-senate-committee-in-support-of-fauci

8:  The Bethesda Declaration: A Call for NIH and HHS Leadership to Deliver on Promises of Academic Freedom and Scientific Excellence:  https://www.standupforscience.net/bethesda-declaration

9:  Yamey G, Titanji B K. Fauci’s Senate hearing riled up the MAGA base—but at the cost of damaging public health BMJ 2026; 394 :e100529 doi:10.1136/bmj-2026-100529  https://www.bmj.com/content/394/bmj-2026-100529


 



Sunday, November 2, 2025

How To Stop Burning Witches...

 


I was hoping for a timely post for Halloween but just missed the deadline. Witches are considered an icon of the season, although I have not seen a lot of those costumes recently. I came across an important book that analyzed the witchmongering movement in 15th to 18th century.   Witchmongering was term was coined by Reginald Scott in 1584 in his book The Discoverie of Witchcraft.  He used it to describe people promoting the ideas and superstitions about witchcraft – specifically those who profited from spreading these ideas.  His book discusses the idea that witches have connections to the devil and Scott’s position was that this was all imaginary.  He studied magic and concluded that the belief in witchcraft was rooted in illusions, imposters, or inaccurate conclusions due to mental disorders.  He sought to prevent marginalized individuals from being attacked as witches.

Despite Scott’s rational approach, witchmongering was actively debated for at least another century.  Thomas Ady wrote A Candle in the Dark in 1656 and took a similar position.  Popular opinion about the existence of witches and their presence began to wane around 1700, but witchcraft laws and executions persisted much longer. In Great Britain the Witchcraft Act was repealed in 1736.  By the late 18th century most witchcraft prosecutions and punishments were banned in Europe. The last witchcraft trial in the US was in 1878.  There is a detailed history of both witch hunts and executions of witches resulting in the deaths of tens of thousands of women.  Even though most people do not know the details of this dark practice – the concept witch hunt is used rhetorically these days to indicate an unfair investigation.  

There are various ways to analyze the history of witchmongering. Social scientists have looked at anthropological and sociopolitical analyses. Rhetoric seems like a powerful approach to me because humans seem to use the same patterns over time to make irrational decisions.  Rhetoric is a component of cultural inheritance.  In the case of witches – anxiety provoking events like crop failures, illnesses, economic and political instability, religious and sexist biases could lead to accusations of witchcraft.  But once the precedent was set behaviors, social factors, and personality factors could also be included as well as accusations of supernatural phenomenon like sorcery and causing people to disappear.  There is no doubt that some had mental illnesses but that is not currently considered to be a major factor in the women who were persecuted.

Ady describes a common scenario in his era. The poor and disabled went door to door in those days asking for relief. Many were elderly, malnourished, and disabled. If they were denied assistance by the landowner and his crops or cattle failed or one of his family fell ill – that person could be blamed for witchcraft as a source for these problems.  They could be subjected to false tests or torture and sentenced to death as a witch.  

Once these negative qualities were specified as evidence, the sequence of events proceeded in the same manner that can easily be observed in modern American politics.  If enough people are anxious about some matter, it is easy enough to incite them.  Just claim that you are the only person who can solve that problem and find a group that is the modern equivalent of witches to blame.  In recent months we have seen documented and undocumented immigrants, women, non-white minorities, university professors, public health officials, public sector employees, the disabled, the economically disadvantaged, the food insecure, members of the previous administration, and just about anyone who is a critic of the current administration. Scapegoating a small segment of the LGBTQ community may have been the deciding factor in that last Presidential election and it continues to be an issue.

Ady’s book is a tour de force against witchcraft.  He begins his three part treatise by directly confronting popular notions of witchcraft with the Biblical moral code of the day.  He lists 16 – “where is it written” or “it is written” clauses in his introductory “A Dilemma that Cannot bee answered By Witchmongers.”  In the subsequent text he elaborates on how references to witches have been misinterpreted to fuel witch misinformation.  An excerpt of the Dilemma is reproduced below.  Note that the original spellings are preserved:

 


 

At the end of this this volume he gives two excellent counterfactuals to falsify witch mongering. It is clear from these examples that any misfortune can be erroneously ascribed to witches and therefore witch mongering and everything that involves adds no explanatory power.  That is made much worse by the fact that this non-explanation resulted in the deaths of thousands.    

 


 Moral reasoning and rationalism was used to discredit witch mongering but they were not the sole factors.  Johann Weyer (1515-1588) was a Dutch physician who argued that witches were mentally ill suffering from melancholia.  He thought that any confessions of witchcraft were based on delusional thinking.  He published numerous works on witchcraft and magic. 

Medicine, science, and rational thought were not enough to immediately correct the practice of persecuting women as witches.  Pseudoscience and various “tests” were used to prove that a woman was a witch.  Many of these tests defy reason like the pseudoscience of the current era.  For example, one test of a witch was to bind them, throw them into a body of water and see if they float.  Certain marks on the skin were taken to be the marks of a witch.  That included puncture marks inflicted with needles by others – if the puncture wound did not bleed it was considered evidence of a witch. Ady provided counterarguments about why these were inadequate tests.  Needless to say there were no control groups. 

Despite Weyer’s direct observations there are competing theories that social and cultural factors were important.  It is likely that both played a part, with psychiatric etiologies as suggested by Weyer playing the minor part.  If you are identified as a physician who works with a particular problem – it is likely that selection bias is operating in the clinical population that you see and treat.  Cultural symbols are often incorporated into psychotic symptoms.  In 40 years of practice – I saw a handful of people who believed they were Christ-like and many more who believed they were the Antichrist. During the time of Satanic Ritualistic Abuse (SRA) I saw many people who were not delusional but believed that they had witnessed homicidal rituals by satanists.  Those are all modern examples of observations that were not accurate and could be scientifically disproven.

If we agree that witch accusations and persecutions were psychiatric, social, and cultural in origins are there some common factors that might account for these patterns?  Anti-intellectualism is a complex societal problem that has been examined by Hofstader, Pigliucci, and others (3-5).  Hofstader traced some of it back to right wing politics and religion in the 1950s where it still resides today.  Hofstader described 3 forms (antirationalism, anti-elitism, unreflective instrumentalism) to which Rigney added unreflective hedonism and Pigliucci added academic post modernism as a fifth (4).  Pigliucci also added a qualifier that post modernism may be an intellectual anti-science field.   

The refutation of witchmongering is an important lesson for people in modern times. Reasoning and moral reasoning based on Christian principles and local laws eventually carried the day – but it took a long time. Science through early observations of mental illness were a small part of the story.  The most significant aspects of this historical period is focused on cultural inheritance and rhetoric.  Neither of those dimensions is necessarily predicated on the truth.  The commonest ignored pattern is the use of a scapegoat to avoid the reality of the situation or in the worst case divert attention to an emotional topic that is really all part of the scapegoating.

We typically see these issues categorized as hot button issues or culture wars.  They are responsible for large scale irrational decision making about guns, abortion, welfare, religion in schools, banned books, restricted access to voting, racism, misogyny, the medically uninsured, and corporate welfare.  They are currently responsible for the dismantling of basic research, health care, food subsidies, public health, foreign aid, the Department of Justice, the Department of Defense, and the layoffs and firings of 200,000 federal employees.  There is an estimated large death and morbidity toll associated with those decisions.

While we are no longer naming witches and prosecuting them – a lot of the thinking behind that process has been passed along as cultural inheritance and the associated rhetoric.  A significant number of Americans react to it in expected ways.  Recognizing the pattern of scapegoating and the associated emotions is a critical first step.  The second is to figure out what science is and what it is not.  Science is definitely not doing your own research unless you have been trained in the scientific method or (ideally) are a scientist.  The ultimate ability is to be able to use reason, moral reason, and science to make the best possible decisions.

That is the best way to avoid more witchmongering.      

 

George Dawson, MD, DFAPA   

 

 

 

Graphic Attribution:

“The Witches' Ride' William Holbrook Beard (1870), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

 

References:

1;  The National Archives - UK.  Early Modern witch trials.  https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/education/resources/early-modern-witch-trials/

2:  Schoeneman TJ. Criticisms of the psychopathological interpretation of witch hunts: a review. Am J Psychiatry. 1982 Aug;139(8):1028-32. doi: 10.1176/ajp.139.8.1028. PMID: 7046480.

3:  Hofstadter, R. Anti-intellectualism in American life. Vol. 713. Vintage, 1966.

4:  Rigney D.  Rethinking Hofstadter: three kinds of anti-intellectualism. Sociological Inquiry.  1999.  61(4): 434-451.

5:  Pigliucci M.  Denying evolution – Creationism, science and the nature of science.  Sinauer Associates, Sunderland MA, 2002.   

6:  Ady T.  A Candle in the Dark or A Treatise Concerning the Nature of Witches and Witchcraft: Being Advice to Judges, Sheriffes, Justices of the Peace, and Grand Jury-men, what to do, before they pass Sentence on such as are arraigned for their Lives as Witches.  1656.  Theophania Publishing.